Reviewer Guidelines

Reviewer Guidelines

Thank you for supporting Informática y Sistemas. Reviewers are essential to the quality of the journal. All reviews follow a double-blind process: reviewers and authors do not know each other’s identity.

Your part in the editorial flow

The complete process, from submission to online publication, takes up to 3 months (90 days). Reviewers take part in three moments:

  1. Invitation: respond within 7 days.
  2. Review: submit your report within 21 days. The editor makes a decision within 4 days of receiving the reviews.
  3. Verification: if revisions are required, you may be asked to verify the changes within 15 days. There are up to two revision rounds.

1. Before accepting

  • Accept only manuscripts within your expertise.
  • Declare any conflict of interest with the authors or the topic.
  • If you cannot review, decline at once so that another reviewer can be invited.

2. What to evaluate

  • Originality and relevance to the journal’s scope.
  • Methodological rigor and reproducibility.
  • Consistency between results, discussion, and conclusions.
  • Clarity of writing in English and quality of figures and tables.
  • Relevance, timeliness, and correct citation of references.

Recommendation

Select one of the following options in the review form:

  • Accept Submission: publishable as it is.
  • Revisions Required: minor changes, checked by the editor without a new review.
  • Resubmit for Review: major changes that require a new review round.
  • Resubmit Elsewhere: outside the scope of the journal.
  • Decline Submission: not publishable.

Ethical responsibilities

  • Keep the manuscript confidential and do not share it.
  • Do not upload the manuscript to generative AI tools.
  • Suggest citations to your own work or to this journal only when scientifically justified.
  • Manuscripts sent for review have passed the originality check of the journal: a maximum of 10% similarity with other sources (excluding quotations and references) and a maximum of 30% of content identified as generated by artificial intelligence.
  • If you detect possible plagiarism, undeclared use of generative AI or references that cannot be verified, report it to the editor in the confidential comments of the review form.

Become a reviewer

To join our reviewer board, register on the platform, select the Reviewer role, and add your areas of expertise in your profile. You may also write to revista.iys@utm.edu.ec.